Dec 20, 2019
D3football.com Offensive Player of the Year: Broc Rutter, QB, North Central.
D3football.com Defensive Player of the Year: Dallas McRae, DT, Wheaton.
D3football.com Coach of the Year: Jeff Thorne, North Central.
| First team offense | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| QB | Broc Rutter | North Central | Sr. | Naperville, Ill. |
| RB | Robert Shufford | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. | McKenzie, Ala. |
| RB | Josh Parks | St. Thomas | Sr. | Chisago City, Minn. |
| WR | Justin Hill | Mount Union | Sr. | Circleville, Ohio |
| WR | Andrew Kamienski | North Central | Jr. | Pingree Grove, Ill. |
| TE | Dan Allen | Delaware Valley | Sr. | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| T | Ben Bartch | St. John’s | Sr. | Dayton, Ore. |
| G | Sharmore Clarke | North Central | Jr. | Oak Park, Ill. |
| C | Zach Smith | Hope | Sr. | Suttons Bay, Mich. |
| G | Garrett Garza | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Round Rock, Texas |
| T | Joe Krall | Monmouth | Sr. | New Berlin, Wis. |
| First team defense | ||||
| DE | Michael Nobile | Delaware Valley | So. | Brick, N.J. |
| DT | Dallas McRae | Wheaton | Sr. | Crown Point, Ind. |
| DT | Joey Longoria | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Pearland, Texas |
| DE | Frankie Feaster | Muhlenberg | Sr. | Montvale, N.J. |
| LB | Tevin Jones | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Belton, Texas |
| LB | Dillon Keefe | Chapman | Jr. | Orange, Calif. |
| LB | Emmett Forde | Hobart | Jr. | South Boston, Mass. |
| CB | Danial Shelton | Susquehanna | Sr. | District Heights, Md. |
| S | Jefferson Fritz | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jr. | Kaufman, Texas |
| S | Raeqwon Greer | Alfred | Jr. | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| CB | Obasi Dees | Cal Lutheran | Sr. | Antioch, Calif. |
| First team specialists | ||||
| K | Jon Alberts | Central | Sr. | Huntley, Ill. |
| P | Alex Berg | Concordia-Moorhead | Sr. | Moorhead, Minn. |
| RET | A.J. Jackson | Lake Forest | Fr. | Peoria, Ariz. |
| ST | Willie Julkes | Concordia-Moorhead | Sr. | Mesa, Ariz. |
| Second team offense | ||||
| QB | Jackson Erdmann | St. John’s | Sr. | Rosemount, Minn. |
| RB | Wesley Schools | Grove City | Sr. | Port Jervis, N.Y. |
| RB | Ethan Greenfield | North Central | So. | Lindenhurst, Ill. |
| WR | Cole Spieker | UW-La Crosse | Sr. | Brainerd, Minn. |
| WR | AJ Johnson | Puget Sound | Sr. | Tacoma, Wash. |
| TE | Colton Jewell | Aurora | Sr. | Lake Villa, Ill. |
| T | Sean Sherman | Mount Union | Sr. | Springboro, Ohio |
| G | Dan Greenheck | St. John’s | Sr. | St. Paul, Minn. |
| C | Mike Olsen | UW-Oshkosh | Jr. | Hartland, Wis. |
| G | Quinn Meinerz | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Hartford, Wis. |
| T | Tyler Norwood | Salisbury | Sr. | Milford, Del. |
| Second team defense | ||||
| DE | Mackenzie Balanganayi | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Palatine, Ill. |
| DT | J.W. Windsor | St. John’s | Sr. | Mesa, Ariz. |
| DT | Conner Bogard | John Carroll | Sr. | Cleveland, Ohio |
| DE | Jordan McInerney | Lake Forest | Sr. | Libertyville, Ill. |
| LB | Sam Romanski | UW-Eau Claire | Sr. | Wausau, Wis. |
| LB | Mark Niles | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Miramar, Fla. |
| LB | Antonio Johnson | N.C. Wesleyan | Sr. | Beaufort, N.C. |
| CB | Keith Gipson | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Killeen, Texas |
| S | Mark McGrath | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Lisle, Ill. |
| S | James Bell | Texas Lutheran | Jr. | Houston, Texas |
| CB | Justin Harris | Delaware Valley | Jr. | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| Second team specialists | ||||
| K | Jaydon Haag | UW-Oshkosh | So. | Sparta, Wis. |
| P | Zach Warcola | TCNJ | Sr. | Mendham, N.J. |
| RET | Tahmir Barksdale | Delaware Valley | Fr. | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| ST | AJ Christensen | Coe | So. | Leaf River, Ill. |
| Third team offense | ||||
| QB | D’Angelo Fulford | Mount Union | Sr. | Miramar, Fla. |
| RB | Jaquan Hemphill | Hardin-Simmons | Sr. | Coleman, Texas |
| RB | Ike Irabor | Union | So. | Braintree, Mass. |
| WR | Mason Kinsey | Berry | Sr. | Demorest, Ga. |
| WR | James Gillespie | Widener | Sr. | Huntingdon Valley, Pa. |
| TE | Ryan Curtiss | Muhlenberg | Sr. | Franklin Lakes, N.J. |
| T | Ryan Malarkey | Muhlenberg | Sr. | Jim Thorpe, Pa. |
| G | DoRion Dreighton | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jr. | San Antonio, Texas |
| C | Jake Hibben | Wheaton | Sr. | Littleton, Colo. |
| G | Jonny Todd | Mount Union | Sr. | Canton, Ohio |
| T | Austin Baiardi | Trinity (Conn.) | Sr. | Smithtown, N.Y. |
| Third team defense | ||||
| DE | Liam Vincifora | Millsaps | Jr. | Covington, La. |
| DT | Ben James | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Virginia Beach, Va. |
| DT | Elias Hackney | Redlands | Sr. | Santa Monica, Calif. |
| DE | John Hadac | Ithaca | Sr. | Greene, N.Y. |
| LB | Ryan Schwartz | Wheaton | Jr. | Burbank, Ohio |
| LB | Re’Shaun Myers | Bridgewater | Sr. | Ringgold, Va. |
| LB | Nick Milgate | Alfred | Sr. | Hilton, N.Y. |
| CB | Spencer Rowland | Wheaton | Sr. | Greenville, Mich. |
| S | Kordell Ford | Mount Union | Jr. | Massillon, Ohio |
| S | Jed Schlegel | UW-Stout | Sr. | Baldwin, Wis. |
| CB | Jake Beesley | North Central | Jr. | Champaign, Ill. |
| Third team specialists | ||||
| K | Anthony Avila | Mary Hardin-Baylor | So. | Troy, Texas |
| P | Cole Westberry | Averett | Sr. | Youngsville, N.C. |
| RET | Joey Koroly | Washington & Jefferson | So. | Washington, Pa. |
| ST | Michael Edmonson | Trinity (Texas) | Jr. | Holly Lake Ranch, Texas |
| Honorable mention offense | ||||
| QB | Gavin Zimbelman | Aurora | Jr. | Menteno, Ill. |
| RB | Alex Minton | Denison | Jr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| RB | Christiaan Williams | Ohio Northern | Jr. | Sidney, Ohio |
| WR | Will Gladney | Ithaca | Sr. | Binghamton, N.Y. |
| WR | Colt Morgan | Case Western Reserve | Jr. | Wooster, Ohio |
| TE | Brayton Finch | Gustavus Adolphus | Sr. | Mount Morris, Ill. |
| T | Austin Lewter | Birmingham-Southern | Sr. | Tanner, Ala. |
| G | Luke Lodini | Brockport | Jr. | Stony Point, N.Y. |
| C | Patrick Quintana | Trinity (Texas) | Sr. | McKinney, Texas |
| G | Brady Hogue | Westminster (Pa.) | Sr. | Sharpsville, Pa. |
| T | Frank Zoltan | Denison | Sr. | Evanston, Ill. |
| Honorable mention defense | ||||
| DE | Tim Ousley | Muskingum | Sr. | McArthur, Ohio |
| DT | Mike Williams | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| DT | Kenyonn Jones | Delaware Valley | Sr. | Burlington, N.J. |
| DE | Patrick O’Connell | Wheaton | Sr. | Long Grove, Ill. |
| LB | Keyell Davis | Linfield | Sr. | Gig Harbor, Wash. |
| LB | Cole Dixon | Susquehanna | Sr. | Dallas, Pa. |
| LB | Kaleb Kaminski | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Tomahawk, Wis. |
| CB | Jeff Hector | Redlands | Sr. | Palos Verdes Peninsula, Calif. |
| S | Sean Carroll | Salisbury | Jr. | Wilmington, Del. |
| S | Nick Heidel | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| CB | Chris Harris | St. John’s | Sr. | Lake Elsinore, Calif. |
| Honorable mention specialists | ||||
| K | Maki Medici | Utica | Jr. | Watervliet, N.Y. |
| P | Joey Annee | Wabash | So. | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| RET | Jermaine Russell | Guilford | Jr. | Durham, N.C. |
| ST | Logan Grauer | Lebanon Valley | So. | Mohrsville, Pa. |