| First Team |
Second Team |
| Offense |
| QB |
Scott Krause, Sr., UW-Stevens Point |
Dan Cole, Sr., RPI |
| RB |
Tony Sutton, Jr., Wooster |
Dan Price, Sr., Wheaton |
| RB |
Brett Trichilo, Jr., Wilkes |
Andrew Mocadlo, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| WR |
Blake Elliott, Sr., St. John's |
Conrad Singh, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| WR |
Mark Bartosic, Sr., Susquehanna |
Flynn Cochran, Sr., RPI |
| TE |
Scott Marek, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
Kyle Acker, Sr., Salisbury |
| OT |
Larry Kinnard, Sr., Mount Union |
Jeff Oliver, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| OG |
Brian Dewey, Jr., Springfield |
Jeff Voreis, Sr., Wartburg |
| C |
Tom Doyle, Sr., Capital |
Billy Joe Murray, Sr., Willamette |
| OG |
James Hoxworth, Sr., Wheaton |
Adam Hernandez, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
| OT |
Ben Knepper, Sr., UW-Stout |
Matt Miller, Sr., Louisiana College |
| Defense |
| DE |
Jarrod Smith, Sr., Trinity (Texas) |
Nate Mitchell, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace |
| DT |
Blair Hammer, Sr., Wabash |
Antoine Dillard, Sr., Mount Union |
| DT |
Vince King, Sr., Wartburg |
Brandon Tisdale, Jr., Wilmington |
| DE |
Jeremy Hood, Sr. St. John's |
Sean McGinley, Sr., Lycoming |
| LB |
Jermaine Taylor, Sr., Bridgewater (Va.) |
Greg Washington, Jr., East Texas Baptist |
| LB |
Ron Swearingin, Sr., Capital |
Graham Goldwasser, Sr., Williams |
| LB |
Casey Carlson, Sr., Pacific Lutheran |
Matt O'Bryant, Sr., Millsaps |
| CB |
Joe Masciopinto, Sr., St. Norbert |
Kyle Westphal, Jr., Simpson |
| S |
Greg Koch, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace |
Sam Lacy, Sr., Bethel |
| S |
Frank Pilato, Jr., Washington and Jefferson |
Carlo DeAngelo, Sr., Delaware Valley |
| CB |
Alex Hansen, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
Quammie Semper, Sr., Oberlin |
| DB/WR |
Cody Kelley, Sr., Wartburg |
|
| Specialists |
| K |
Mike Clark, Jr., Augustana |
Treavor Smith, So., Fitchburg State |
| P |
James Wilson, Jr., Linfield |
Scott Verhalen, Sr., East Texas Baptist |
| RET |
Jamarcus Shephard, Jr., DePauw |
Derek Stanley, Fr. UW-Whitewater |