Offensive Player of the Year: Cecil Shorts, WR,
Mount Union
Defensive Player of the Year: Eddie Vallery, DE,
Wittenberg
Coach of the Year: Lance Leipold,
UW-Whitewater
| First Team | Second Team | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Dan Whalen, Sr., Case Western Reserve | Alex Tanney, Jr., Monmouth |
| RB | Levell Coppage, So., UW-Whitewater | Caleb Jennings, Jr., Emory and Henry |
| RB | Ben Wartman, Jr., St. Thomas | Jim Bower, Sr., Maine Maritime |
| WR | Cecil Shorts, Sr., Mount Union | Jeff Koeneman, Sr., Carthage |
| WR | Alex Koors, Jr., DePauw | Michael Zweifel, Jr., Dubuque |
| TE | Renard Ellis, Sr., Mississippi College | Kyle Miller, Sr., Mount Union |
| T | Blaine Westemeyer, Sr., Augustana | Sean Tetreault, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
| G | Matt Weber, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Andrew Benchic, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| C | Dillon Hollin, Sr., Wittenberg | Josh Ostrue, Jr., St. Thomas |
| G | Scott Millenbach, Sr., Linfield | Josh Lankford, Sr., Mississippi College |
| T | Caleb Crowl, Sr., Mount Union | Evan Isaacs, Sr., Wabash |
|
Defense |
||
| DE | Eddie Vallery, Jr., Wittenberg | Joe Millings, Sr., Mount Union |
| DT | Gerard Bryant, Sr., St. Lawrence | Matt Grieves, Sr., Heidelberg |
| DT | Matt Williamson, Sr., Mount Union | Mike Ward, Sr., Wesley |
| DE | Marcus Ball, Sr., UW-Stout | Alex Wertheimer, Jr., Occidental |
| LB | Kyle Gesswein, Jr., Delaware Valley | Nick Nikolich, Sr., Illinois Wesleyan |
| LB | Sam Kershaw, Jr., Mount Union | Kyle Supianoski, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| LB | Will Hawkins, Jr., Millsaps | Brad Steinmetz, Sr., Thomas More |
| CB | Josh Mathieu, Sr., Westfield State | Dominique Dixon, Sr., Montclair State |
| S | Addrian Frederick, Sr., Wabash | Fred Argir, Sr., Amherst |
| S | Bill Doody, Jr., Hampden-Sydney | Aaron Benson, Jr., Wesley |
| CB | Brandon Hudson, Sr., Salisbury | Brett Parker, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
|
Specialists |
||
| AP | Bryson Tucker, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | |
| K | Jeff Schebler, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Dan Winsey, Jr., Concordia (Wis.) |
| P | Alex Groh, Sr., Occidental | Tyler Funk, Sr., Carthage |
| RET | Fritz Waldvogel, So., St. Thomas | Jeremy Dixon, Jr., Averett |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Kurt Rocco, Sr., Mount Union | Jeff Donovan, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| RB | Brent Donley, Jr., Ohio Northern | Dave Paveletz, Sr., Susquehanna |
| RB | Andrew Kase, Sr., Johns Hopkins | DeRon Brown, Sr., MIT |
| WR | Nate Romig, Sr., Albright | Pat Noone, So., Bowdoin |
| WR | Craig Besong, Sr., Washington and Jefferson | Earl Peoples, Jr., Randolph-Macon |
| TE | Zach Friedrich, Sr., Greenville | Sean McAndrew, Jr., Wesley |
| T | Josh Delancy, Sr., North Central (Ill.) | Zac Duval, Sr., Plymouth State |
| G | Colin Berry, Sr., Union | Tony Opperman, So., Case Western Reserve |
| C | Dustin Davis, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Garth Coats, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| G | Travis McBride, Sr., Redlands | Anthony Walsh, Sr., Mount St. Joseph |
| T | Travis Boothe, Sr., Illinois Wesleyan | Mike Long, Jr., Delaware Valley |
|
Defense |
||
| DE | James Herbert, Sr., Mount Union | Frank Weymiller, Fr., Coe |
| DT | Chris Merkle, Sr., Montclair State | Ben Tomaino, Sr., Hartwick |
| DT | Kyle Schroeder, Sr., St. John's | LeeRon Boykin, Sr., North Carolina Wesleyan |
| DE | Chris Mayes, So., Wesley | Will Riggenbach, Jr., Hampden-Sydney |
| LB | Ralph Pineda, Jr., Willamette | Kyle Chewning, Sr., Maryville (Tenn.) |
| LB | Quartez Ashmore, Sr., Mississippi College | Andy Episcopo, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| LB | Judd Lutz, Sr., Mount Union | Andrew Sellers, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| CB | Troney Shumpert, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Kendall Wade, Sr., UW-Stout |
| S | Drew McClain, Sr., Mount Union | Jarin Davis, Sr., Concordia (Ill.) |
| S | Don Bladt, Sr., Cornell | Drew Fisher, So., Linfield |
| CB | Zach Autenreib, Fr., Thomas More | Corry Stewart, Sr., Hanover |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Garrett Biel, Fr., Trinity (Texas) | Tony Smidl, Sr., UW-Platteville |
| P | Kyle Trella, Fr., Trinity (Texas) | Chris Stengel, Jr., Westfield State |
| RET | Jarred Burrell, Sr., Springfield | Wes Chamblee, Jr., Wabash |