Offensive Player of the Year: Nate Kmic, RB,
Mount Union
Defensive Player of the Year: Jace Rindahl, LB,
UW-Whitewater
Coach of the Year: Lance Leipold,
UW-Whitewater
| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Greg Micheli, Sr., Mount Union | Chad Rupp, Sr., Franklin |
| RB | Nate Kmic, Sr., Mount Union | DeRon Brown, Jr., MIT |
| RB | Tunde Ogun, Jr., Christopher Newport | Adam Anderson, Jr., Whitworth |
| WR | Jack Phelan, Sr., Hartwick | Merben Woo, Sr., Willamette |
| WR | Royce Winford, Sr., Augsburg | Mychal Carillo, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| TE | Jon Lanouette, Sr, Wesley | Brad Kalsow, Sr., UW-Stevens Point |
| T | Luke Summers, Sr., Mount Union | John Szawlowski, Sr., Williams |
| G | Josh Littlejohn, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Josh Kotecki, Jr., Monmouth |
| C | Ryan Hunter, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Josh Ostrue, Jr., St. Thomas |
| G | Mike Sherman, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Sam Emerson, Sr., Occidental |
| T | Jesse Scott, Sr., Wheaton (Ill.) | Jake Forshey, Sr., Willamette |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Jarrell Chandler, Sr, Salisbury | Marcus Ball, Jr., UW-Stout |
| DT | Brad Vickroy, Sr., UW-Stevens Point | Darryl Kennon, Sr., Wabash |
| DT | Gerard Bryant, Jr., St. Lawrence | Jake Fallis, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| DE | James Herbert, Jr., Mount Union | Brock Arndt, Sr., Redlands |
| LB | Eric Henri, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sean Matthews, Sr., Wesley |
| LB | Matt Scalice, Sr., Ithaca | Justin Hager, Sr., Hobart |
| LB | Jace Rindahl, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Matt Wenger, Jr., North Central |
| CB | Pete Ittersagen, Sr., Wheaton (Ill.) | Kendale Rayford, Sr., Lousiana College |
| S | Drew Ziller, Sr., Carleton | Matt Warnasch, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| S | Derrick Williams, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | John Lunardi, Sr., Susquehanna |
| CB | Jason Chier, Sr., Ithaca | Matt Meyer, Sr., Aurora |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Scott Birkhofer, Sr., Linfield | Jeff Schebler, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| P | Alex Groh, Jr., Occidental | Bobby Eppleman, So., Susquehanna |
| RET | Larry Beavers, Sr., Wesley | Pete Ittersagen, Sr., Wheaton |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Juan Joseph, Sr., Millsaps | Bobby Swallow, Sr., Washington & Jefferson |
| RB | Levell Coppage, Fr., UW-Whitewater | Alex McGrew, Sr., Loras |
| RB | John DeLuca, Sr., Muhlenberg | Andrew Giuliano, Sr., Cortland State |
| WR | Kevin Vaughn, Sr., Guilford | Michael Jennings, Jr., Illinois College |
| WR | Cecil Shorts, Jr., Mount Union | Pat O'Connor, Jr., Dickinson |
| TE | Brian Weverbergh, Sr., Ithaca | Jerrad Grisham, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| T | Andy Fries, Sr., Otterbein | Ralph Stambaugh, Sr., Delaware Valley |
| G | John Shivers, Jr., Millsaps | Dustin Tervelt, Sr., UW-Stout |
| C | Brendan Kelly, Sr., Middlebury | Tony Neymeyier, Sr., Wabash |
| G | Chris Gray, Sr., Ithaca | James Olenik, Sr., MIT |
| T | Brian Fitzgerald, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Chris Gould, Sr., Kean |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Ben Nagle, Sr., Cortland State | Anthony White, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| DT | Luke Stover, Sr., Simpson | Jake Zeh, Sr., Carroll |
| DT | Ryan Aruck, Sr., Hobart | Matt Williamson, Jr., Mount Union |
| DE | Dan McManus, Sr., Franklin | Jacob Calderon, Sr., Cal Lutheran |
| LB | Courtney Pearson, Sr., Trine | Cornell Hunt, Sr., Montclair State |
| LB | Matt Rathbun, Sr., Muhlenberg | Jim Smith, Sr., Cortland State |
| LB | Randy Wright, So., Elmhurst | Drew Kiefer, Sr., UW-La Crosse |
| CB | Daryl Ely, Sr., Mount Union | Troney Shumpert, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| S | Joe Welch, Jr., Gustavus Adolphus | Tom Tassinari, Jr., Tufts |
| S | Carlo Melaragno, Sr., John Carroll | Josh Kraemer, Sr., Ripon |
| CB | Victor Edwards, Jr., Cal Lutheran | Nick Olivero, Sr., Catholic |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Alan Munoz, So., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jackson Damron, Fr., Cal Lutheran |
| P | T.J. Grzesikowski, So., Ferrum | Ryan Patten, Jr., Olivet |
| RET | Scott Cree, Jr., Waynesburg | Caleb Jennings, So., Emory and Henry |