It was tough going on offense
for anyone on either side. UMHB athletics photo |
BELTON, Texas -- Justin Beaver you know. UW-Whitewater teammates
Justin Jacobs and Derek Stanley might also ring a bell. Warhawks
tight end Pete Schmitt you may remember from his key play in the
Stagg Bowl, fullback Travis Reuland from his ties to Beaver and
Brady Ramseier and Max Sakellaris were all-American linemen.
Josh Welch quarterbacked Mary Hardin-Baylor in the Stagg Bowl two
years ago and Freddie Rollins rushed for the touchdown and
two-point conversion that tied the game at 21.
Outside their home conferences, the recognizable names from the
past two Stagg Bowl runners-up were all offensive players. After
Saturday's 7-3 Whitewater victory, the nation's Division III
onlookers should get familiar with defensive tackle Ryan Kleppe and
his fellow Warhawks, as well as free safety Josh Kubiak and his
fellow Crusaders.
"Last year our offense overshadowed our defense," said Kleppe, "and
this year, they're just as good."
One wouldn't have been able to tell on Saturday, as the defenses so
dominated two offenses that they managed just a field goal between
them. But the game was never boring, and considering the need for
defense during a long playoff run, both teams should have come away
encouraged.
"I feel bad about the loss, but I still feel good about the way we
played," said Kubiak, who was talking to me for the second time
after a game the Crusaders very well could have won and lost.
The defensive statistics are overwhelming.
Since Neil Mrkvicka's 94-yard kickoff return on the opening play
accounted for the game's only touchdown, UMHB's defense pitched a
shutout against a team averaging 40 points and 422 yards per game
coming in. They were coming off 45- and 49-point performances
against two of the best teams in the Wisconsin Intercollegiate
Athletic Conference. Star running back Beaver was missing, but he
wouldn't have made a huge difference Saturday. The speedy,
gang-tackling Crusaders were smothering everything. Whitewater
finished with eight first downs, 30 yards rushing, 120 total yards
and were 2-of-12 on third down.
The Warhawks basically did the same from the time Kleppe sacked
Welch on the fourth and fifth plays of the game. Relying more on
brute strength and solid technique, the Warhawks had Mary
Hardin-Baylor abandoning the option and double- and triple-teaming
linemen in the first half. UMHB came in averaging 36 points per
game and 307 yards, including 201 rushing. They finished with 13
first downs, 49 yards rushing, 204 total yards and were 3-of-13 on
third down.
Mount Union and Rowan have the No. 2 and 3 defenses in the country,
statistically. Given Saturday's performances against premier
offenses, Mary Hardin-Baylor and Whitewater each look worthy of No.
1 accolades. If the Profs rebound, those teams could create a
defensive-minded final four.
But after the loss, Kubiak, who had nine tackles, two pass breakups
and a sack, was in no mood to look that far ahead. The Crusaders'
final two opponents, he pointed out, had either won the conference
(East Texas Baptist, 2003) or beaten them last season (Howard
Payne). Victories in those American Southwest Conference games will
set up a first-round playoff game on Belton High School's field,
against someone other than Hardin-Simmons, the ASC opponent UMHB
beat 28-16 on Oct. 7.
"We knew that this wouldn't affect whether we make the playoffs or
not, but we still took it really seriously," Kubiak said. "We
wanted to win."
The Crusaders probably should have. UMHB dinked a 47-yard field
goal attempt off the high school uprights, threw an interception on
the 12 at the end of the first half and settled for a late 27-yard
field goal after driving to the Whitewater 4-yard line.
On the flipside, that the only scoring drive of the day, lasting
seven plays and covering 5 yards following a Jacobs fumble with
9:51 left. On the longest drive of the day, UMHB took 14 plays to
go 59 yards, but they twice got first downs on Whitewater
penalties.
The Warhawk defense that buckled down in crunch time, and really
hasn't been tested since 2005 games against Mount Union, Linfield
and UW-La Crosse, might finally get the respect it
deserves.
"There was nobody quitting when Jake fumbled," said Kleppe of his
quarterback's fumble at the 15-yard line. "It was kind of like
'What are you made of?'"
Cornerback Gabe Schultz, perhaps the smallest player in the lineup
listed at 5-6, 178, showed what he was made of on a key play after
the fumble.
On second-and-goal from the 11 two plays after a holding penalty,
Welch lofted a fade to 6-2 freshman receiver Fred Cumby. Cumby
caught the ball with both hands, but with safety Ben Farley draped
over top of him, Schultz stripped the ball before Cumby feet
touched the ground. If there were replay in Division III anywhere
besides the Stagg Bowl, it would have been reviewed. As it stood,
it was the four-point difference in the game.
"You've got to use whatever you've got," said Schultz, who was
looking for either a fade or a slant and lined up to take the slant
away.
It was an odd day for Whitewater's defenders, who didn't figure
they'd have to make a game-opening kick return stand up, and didn't
expect to be shouting out the punter in post-game interviews. When
Kleppe noted that "Nick Croak did a great job for us," he was no
doubt referencing the Warhawks punter's was part in the defensive
effort: Nine punts for 394 yards, with four inside the 20 and three
for 50 yards or longer.
Kleppe, a 6-0, 290-pound senior had perhaps his best day ever, with
10 tackles, three sacks and five and a half tackles for losses. He
attributed some of the success to having his "arm back," since he
broken in the season-opening win against Lakeland and played with
it wrapped for several weeks.
The benchmark day for the Whitewater defense started with a
familiar goal, Kleppe said.
"We stress stopping the run first, which makes teams
one-dimensional."
On the flipside, the Crusaders' success comes from an array of
blitzes, solid coverage and lightning-quick pursuit to the
ball.
"Our linebackers are extremely fast," said Kubiak. "We take a lot
of pride in our team speed on defense. I don't know how many times
I've heard 'em say 'we're too fast, you can't run on us.' "
Derek Underwood only took one of his 20 carries longer than eight
yards, but his late 20-yarder helped Whitewater pin the Crusaders
deep for their final unsuccessful drive. The Warhawks missed their
best scoring chance when freshman kicking sensation Jeff Schebler
missed a third-quarter 50-yarder, he too hitting an upright.
Whitewater left Texas both tested and intact, although Reuland,
their best pass protector, was injured late in the game. The
Warhawks are 8-0 and recognize that they're beatable, putting them
in the proper mind-set to handle stiff playoff challenges.
Mary Hardin-Baylor has two losses by a total of eight points, with
a drive inside the 5 in the waning minutes of each. Kubiak said the
loss was a confidence-builder, and upsets aside, the Crusaders look
like the second seed in the South playoff bracket behind
Wesley.
Tour
report
Keith McMillan burns the 2 a.m. (3 a.m. ET) oil. Photo by Pat Coleman, D3sports.com |
On the third of four trips for Around the Nation's Run to the
Playoffs -- and thank the Lord the last weekend morning on a 6 a.m.
flight -- Pat Coleman and I actually made it to Austin the night
before, and headed to Belton for UW-Whitewater's visit to Mary
Hardin-Baylor.
The two teams had scheduled this game for the chance to play top
competition, and both got the test they wanted. Whitewater, which
had to convince UW-Oshkosh to move their scheduled game to Sept.
23, already plays the toughest teams in its general area with its
conference schedule.
This game and Linfield/Hardin-Simmons were probably the top two
non-conference, non-traditional matchups of the season, and we
applaud all four teams for taking those games.
Belton, and Texas in general, was as hospitable as anywhere I've
ever been for Division III football. We were able to put faces on a
handful of message board handles, and also ran into fans who said
they read and don't post, which is fine too. The hospitality took
us up the road to Sorge's Italian Restaurant in Temple, which I
don't mind plugging because of its Division III ties. The owners,
Gary and David Sorge, are natives of Alliance, Ohio, home of Mount
Union. Also, apparently some of the meetings when UMHB was
discussing adding a program were held there.
When you see what Mary Hardin-Baylor has done on campus with its
basketball and baseball facilities, it's easy to wonder why they
don't yet have an on-campus football palace. But the program is
well taken care of in its field house, and the Belton High School
stadium is just on the other side of an overpass.
In a true testament to the enormity of high school football in
Texas, the home of the Tigers (aka the Big Red) seats 8,000, and
has a turf field. The turf is free of team-oriented markings, so
the Crusaders can throw a few banners up on game day and adopt the
stadium.
From the top row of seats and press box, at least eight water
towers are visible. The landscape is flat and mountain-free for as
far as the eye can see, which might be all the way to Waco on a
clear day.
Saturday will bring Around the Nation to Glassboro, N.J., for
Cortland State's visit to Rowan. Whitworth at Linfield will be just
as big a game, but I don't think I can take another flight this
week. To the true frequent flyers, I don't know how you do it.
Poll positions / My
26-35
One of the three top 25 voters who was voting for UW-Whitewater No.
1 overall appears to have flipped after Mount Union beat Capital
38-12, albeit at home, and Whitewater overcame No. 6 Mary
Hardin-Baylor in Texas, 7-3.
I don’t think the overflow teams, those creeping up on No. 25
on my ballot, are that interesting this week. Not too many shocks
in this un-ordered group: Williams, Trinity (Texas), Washington
& Jefferson, North Central, Wheaton, Carnegie Mellon, Bethel,
St. Olaf, St. Norbert, Curry, Dickinson, Averett, Alfred, Coe and
RPI.
Sul Ross State proved itself not quite ready for the big time, and
Washington & Lee did not look good against Bridgewater.
Five games to
watch
Another huge weekend is on tap, after we had to look at 15 games to
watch last Saturday.
No. 10 Whitworth (8-0) at No. 15 Linfield
(5-2)
Major implications here, for both the Northwest Conference title
(neither has an NWC loss) and for Pool B playoff bids, not to
mention teams in Pool C hoping none of their bids are snapped up by
overflow Pool B teams. The Wildcats don't seem to be the same team
that dominated the West the past few seasons, but a five-game
streak of victories has secured consecutive winning season No. 51,
likely erasing doubts that may have set in after season-opening
losses to Division II Western Oregon and then-and-now-No. 7
Hardin-Simmons. Keen stat-watchers know the record of Whitworth's
opponents is only 17-43, but the Pirates haven't allowed more than
16 points in a game. That average is just nine over the past five
games, a period in which Linfield has scored 37 points per. The
trip to McMinnville is significant for Whitworth, and they might
still be a playoff team with a loss. Linfield doesn't have that
luxury and needs the season-defining win against a team that hasn't
stayed within 11 points of it since 2001 and hasn't beaten it since
1975.
No. 12 Cortland State (8-0) at No. 17 Rowan
(5-2)
The Profs are in a win-or-miss-the-playoffs situation, a potential
Pool C bid damaged by last week's 27-20 stumble at Montclair State.
They can still win their fifth NJAC championship in the past six
years by defeating the Red Dragons. A Cortland loss would mean they
would meet Ithaca in a win-or-go-home Cortaca Jug game. The Red
Dragons could be the East's No. 1 seed or miss the postseason
entirely. Cortland's defense has allowed three points in two weeks,
since TCNJ's 14 points last week came on a interception return and
blocked punt return. Quirky scores may influence Saturday's game,
since the Profs have a defense to match (No. 3 in nation at 161.9
yards per game to Cortland's No. 19 and 221.4). Rowan has given up
75 rushing yards all season, bad news for a Cortland team playing
with backup quarterback Ray Miles in place of Alex Smith
No. 20 Union (6-1) at No. 14 Hobart (7-0)
Both of these teams seem to be less dominant than their fans
expected after last season's playoff runs, but each is poised to go
back. Union can clinch the Liberty League with a win, but Hobart
still needs to beat 6-2 Rochester in its finale to wrap the league
up. The Statesmen also make good Pool C candidates, although the
Dutchmen, who lost to Springfield 38-30 early on, cannot afford
another defeat. The statistical comparison does not really favor
either team, with Union's 210 rushing yards per game being the only
outstanding stat. The Dutchmen are slightly more impressive on
offense, and the two are about equal on defense. Union's Tom
Arcidiacono is the nation's third-leading rusher, and went for 85
yards and a score in last season's 28-18 win vs. Hobart.
No. 16 Ithaca at Alfred (6-2)
The middle game in a brutal season-ending three-game stretch for
both holds different opportunities for the Bombers and Saxons.
Ithaca has given up just a touchdown a game in its last four; 28
points since St. John Fisher's 34-point second half, and is coming
off a 24-7 win over Springfield. A victory would set up a Cortaca
Jug game with major playoff bid implications. The Saxons are 6-2
and seemingly out of the playoff mix, even with season-ending
victories over Ithaca and Fisher. The 41-34 loss to Springfield
means they would likely take the Empire 8 title, and a 21-14 loss
to Hobart probably means no Pool C for Alfred. A shame, perhaps,
for a team that proved itself a touchdown shy of two top-20 teams,
but them's the breaks. Alfred, to many the best team left out of
last season's playoffs at 8-2, can match that record with
consecutive victories. The Bombers and Saxons are fairly even
statistically, with each being better on defense. Alfred leads the
E8 in total defense by far.
Averett (6-2) at Christopher Newport (6-2)
The Captains are lucky to still have a title shot after faltering
against North Carolina Wesleyan Saturday, probably marking their
rock bottom in a season that includes a big win over Mary
Hardin-Baylor. For Averett, the season has gone as planned, with
games against Mount Union and Wesley to start the season paving the
way for an unbeaten run through the USAC slate. Now is the time to
earn respect, however, by beating a team with a winning record for
the first time since a 54-34 win against Guilford (5-3) in
mid-September. Pomoco Stadium will likely be alive for this
all-or-nothing USAC tussle.
A quick look at five other games which have conference title,
multiple-team tie and Pool B or C implications:
No. 11 Central (8-0) at Coe (6-2)
The Kohawks, despite losing by a field goal in the rain to
Wartburg, which lost in overtime to Central, have no shot at the
playoffs or IIAC title, and can't force a three-way tie because of
a 32-30 slip-up against Loras. But the Kohawks might be powerful
enough to hand the Dutch their first loss, which could end up
affecting the 7-1 Knights' chances at a Pool C bid.
No. 24 Wheaton (7-1) at Carthage (6-2)
Wheaton falls in behind North Central if the current three-way tie
in the CCIW holds form. The Thunder would be a solid Pool C
candidate. Carthage, which lost to Augustana and Elmhurst, could
help the Cardinals clinch outright a week before playing
them.
Emory and Henry (5-3) at Washington and Lee
(6-2)
Despite the Generals being manhandled by Bridgewater last Saturday,
they have a chance to wrap up the first playoff bid in school
history with a home win. Lose, and four- and five-way ties are
possible in the ODAC. Just as we started to forget about Don
Montgomery and what he did in two decades as Mount Union's
defensive coordinator, the Wasps (3-1 in ODAC play right) are again
contending for a playoff spot.
Franklin (7-1) at Defiance (6-2)
Mount St. Joseph has clinched the HCAC title, but the Grizzlies,
clinging to at-large playoff hopes, battle the Yellowjackets for
second place. Franklin gains 387.1 yards per game, Defiance (No. 9
nationally at 195.5 yards per) brings a strong defense.
Hope (5-3) at Olivet (5-3)
The Comets stumbled two weeks ago against Tri-State, rendering Hope
the likely representative of the MIAA. But Olivet can take the AQ
with a win.
Upset special
Bethany at Carnegie Mellon was very tempting here, but the 4-4
Bison's results are too scattershot to think they'll take down a
rolling Tartans team with playoff aspirations. Millsaps (5-3) was
my pick two weeks ago to knock off DePauw, and this time around,
with a shot at beating Trinity and earning the SCAC's playoff bid
next weekend, could they be looking past 5-3 Rhodes? By records
it's no upset at all, but the Lynx have been non-competitive
against the top teams on their schedule, so a win over the Majors
would be a surprise. It's all on the ability for Millsaps to hold
it together here. Their championship chance will come if they first
focus on winning this Saturday.
So far this year: 4-for-7, although Dickinson's 22-21 win over
Hampden-Sydney marked the second time my upset special lost by one
point (the other was Lycoming's 17-16 loss vs. Delaware
Valley).
Surprisingly Good Game
I'm going to take a shot in the dark at an old "throw out the
record books" rivalry game. The Bronze Turkey is in and out of
hiding, but should be in the house (or somewhere nearby) when Knox
(2-7) and Monmouth (6-3) get together. The Prairie Fire's wins have
come over programs who are a combined 1-16 and I have no real
reason to believe in them other than I've played in enough rivalry
games to know the best team doesn't always win. The Scots were a
playoff team last season and probably had hopes of returning, but
can at least beat their rivals for some solace. In the end,
Monmouth has enough talent to get it done, but not without some
struggle.
So far this year: 5-for-7, as then-No. 5 Wesley hung on to beat 3-5
Salisbury 13-10 on Saturday.
Also keep an eye on -- John Carroll at No. 1 Mount Union, No. 7
Hardin-Simmons at Texas Lutheran, Bethany at Carnegie Mellon,
Carleton at St. Olaf, RPI at Rochester, Amherst at Trinity (Conn.),
Salisbury at Widener, Hampden-Sydney at Johns Hopkins, Albion at
Adrian
Who are those
guys?
A small slate again this week, although a pair of quality Division
III teams are in action. Last week Husson beat La Salle 17-7 and
Newport News beat Southern Virginia 32-0.
vs. Division I-AA (1-0 in Week 9, 7-7 in 2006)
None
vs. Division II (0-0 in Week 9, 4-9 in 2006)
Chowan at No. 4 Wesley
vs. NAIA (1-0 in Week 9, 21-7 in 2006)
Huntingdon at Southwest Assemblies of God
But don't quote me
…
Random tidbits from Week 9 and thoughts on Week 10:
It was a solid weekend for Least Bang for the Buck candidates, a
category that is featured in ATN's Year in Review each season.
Weather wasn't a factor in the UMHB-Whitewater 7-3 game, and around
the country, excuses for poor offensive outputs may vary. Here are
some other candidates:
Hanover 7, Bluffton 6
Carnegie Mellon 10, Wash U. 7 (OT)
Delaware Valley 10, King's 0
Coast Guard 3, Maine Maritime 0
And our likely winner: Colby 10, Bates 7 in four overtimes. (See
photo.)
For those who didn't stay up late enough to scoreboard-watch, Cal
Lutheran had a chance to knock off Occidental. But a 24-7 halftime
lead for the Kingsmen became a 28-27 defeat and the feather in the
Tigers' cap so far.
West Virginia fullback Owen Schmitt, in action Thursday night in a
Division I-A matchup of undefeateds against Louisville, began his
career at UW-River Falls before walking on with the
Mountaineers.
Millikin (2-6) is the only team among the nation's top 25 in run
defense with a losing record. They're 14th.
Your playoff
questions
The D3football.com staff is here for you if you need answers, but
with the NCAA committee's playoff criteria publicly available,
longtime readers have outdone themselves this season on our blog,
The Daily Dose, and Post Patterns, our message board. The fan
analysis is as good as I can remember it, so no need for me to go
overboard. There are fairly comprehensive looks at Pool B and Pool
C under General Football on the message board.
For a week now the Daily Dose has featured a thread called Your
Team's Playoff Chances, specifically for you to ask about the team
you root for and where it stands as of now in the playoff picture.
Also featured there are links to our playoff FAQ, which should help
any of you confused by mentions of Pools A, B and C, in-region
games and Quality of Wins Index.
For print, radio and
Internet journalists
Keith McMillan is available, by appointment, on Thursdays and
Fridays to talk Division III football. For more information, e-mail
Keith.
Attention
SIDs
As always, Around the Nation requests media guides and any other
aids in helping us cover your school or conference this season. For
more information, contact Keith McMillan
at keith@d3football.com, or snail mail to D3football.com,
13055 Carolyn Forest Dr., Woodbridge, Va., 22192.
Links to online media guides are now preferred over mail. In
addition, please do not add my e-mail address to your regular
release lists, but instead use our news release capabilities to
have your information posted on our front page and your team's
page. For more information on how that works and how we can help
each other, contact publisher and editor Pat Coleman at info@d3football.com. Thank
you.