Dec 18, 2015
D3football.com Offensive Player of the Year: Jordan Roberts, RB, St. Thomas
D3football.com Defensive Player of the Year: Tom Lally, DT, Mount Union
D3football.com Coach of the Year: Vince Kehres, Mount Union
| Pos. | First Team | Second Team |
| QB | Joe Callahan, Sr., Wesley | Sam Riddle, Jr., Linfield |
| RB | Mason Zurek, Sr., Wabash | Travis Sparks-Jackson, Sr., La Verne |
| RB | Jordan Roberts, Jr., St. Thomas | Logan Nemeth, Sr., Mount Union |
| WR | Bryce Shade, Jr., Wesley | Matt Boyce, Sr., Gustavus Adolphus |
| WR | Jessie Ramos, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Devon Price, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| TE | Charlie Dowdle, Sr., St. Thomas | Zach Hogya, Sr., Heidelberg |
| T | Sam Versnik, Sr., UW-Oshkosh | Anthony Latina, Sr., John Carroll |
| G | Colin Egan, Sr. Johns Hopkins | Broderick Jenkins, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| C | Eric Pitassi, Sr., Linfield | Mitch Doraty, Jr., Mount Union |
| G | Chase Wilhelms, Sr., Wartburg | Tyler Good, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
| T | David Simmet, Sr., St. Thomas | Matt Snebold, Sr., Wheaton (Ill.) |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Alex Hoff, Sr., Linfield | Teidrick Smith, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| DT | Tom Lally, Sr., Mount Union | Korey Zavala, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| DT | Chyron Brown-Wallace, Jr., St. Lawrence | Tyler McCullen, Sr., Wabash |
| DE | Mike Furda, Sr., Mount Union | Brandon Jones, Sr., Widener |
| LB | Adam Dansdill, Sr., Wheaton (Ill.) | Pierce Thedford, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| LB | Keith Corliss, Sr., Johns Hopkins | Justin Dischler, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| LB | Rashaad Lighty, Sr., Delaware Valley | Hank Spencer, Sr., Mount Union |
| CB | Vincent Beltrano, Sr., Chicago | Tre Jones, Sr., Mount Union |
| S | Alex Kocheff, Sr., Mount Union | Bill Shimko, Sr., Montclair State |
| S | Ryan Winske, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Jack Toner, Jr., Johns Hopkins |
| CB | Leondre Simmon, Sr., St. Lawrence | Kyle Belcher, Sr., Linfield |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Daniel Sobolewski, Sr., Albright | Thomas Woodburn, Sr., Utica |
| P | Nico Francino, Jr., Hardin-Simmons | Tyler Henning, Sr., Coast Guard |
| RET | Jessie Ramos, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Kennedy Johnson, Jr., Linfield |
| Pos. | Third Team | Honorable Mention |
| QB | Matt Pawlowski, Sr., Guilford | Taurice Scott, Sr., Mount Union |
| RB | Jordan Ratliffe, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Sam Benger, So., Carnegie Mellon |
| RB | Sam Sura, Sr., St. John's | Dan Andrews, Jr., Brockport |
| WR | Roman Namdar, Sr., Mount Union | James Okike, Jr., Wesley |
| WR | Adam Smith, Sr., Guilford | Joey Sonnenfeld, Sr., Augsburg |
| TE | Nick Kiourkas, So., Whitworth | Jonathan Schmitt, Sr., Kean |
| T | Michael LaSala, Jr., Washington & Lee | Matthew Gono, So., Wesley |
| G | Peter Gibson, Jr., Wheaton (Ill.) | Jonni Cassano, Jr., Albright |
| C | Spencer Shier, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Andrew Garibaldi, Sr., Carnegie Mellon |
| G | Matthew Schmidt, Sr., Wesley | Michael Frank, Sr., Mount Union |
| T | Tony Koepnick, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Will Hilbert, Jr., St. Thomas |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Andrew Robinson, Sr., UW-Platteville | Ryan Aelker, Sr., Bluffton |
| DT | Tarik Bennett, Sr., Brockport | Peyton Thiry, Jr., St. John's |
| DT | Ryan Winter, Jr., St. Thomas | Heath McCray, Sr., Huntingdon |
| DE | Nick Woodman, Sr., Utica | Brian Khoury, Jr., Carnegie Mellon |
| LB | Andrew Belken, Sr., UW-Platteville | Alex Mangan, Sr., St. Scholastica |
| LB | Darren Dungee, Sr., Rowan | Carter Hanson, Jr., St. John's |
| LB | Max Nacewicz, Sr., Springfield | Jesse Addo, Jr., St. Thomas |
| CB | Austin Davis, Jr., Kean | Quincy Marting, Sr., Washington U. |
| S | Keanu Yamamoto, Sr., Linfield | Drew Fitzmorris, So., Carnegie Mellon |
| S | Jimmy Fairfield-Sonn, Sr., Amherst | Anthony White, Sr., Huntingdon |
| CB | Tyrell Bolden, Sr., Illinois Wesleyan | Victor Bunce, So., Claremont-Mudd-Scripps |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Alex Hallwachs, Sr., Washington U. | Jacob O'Neill, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| P | Tyler Hunt, Sr., Guilford | Tim Willett, Sr., Louisiana College |
| RET | De'Eric Bell, So., Guilford | Josh Bungum, Sr., St. John's |