| First Team | Second Team | |
| Offense | ||
| QB | Alex Tanney, Sr., Monmouth | Justin Feaster, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| RB | Levell Coppage, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Caleb Jennings, Sr., Emory and Henry |
| RB | Ben Wartman, Sr., St. Thomas | Quincy Daniels, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| WR | Cecil Shorts, Sr., Mount Union | Michael Zweifel, Sr., Dubuque |
| WR | Alex Koors, Sr., DePauw | Pat Noone, Jr., Bowdoin |
| TE | Kyle Miller, Sr., Mount Union | Sean McAndrew, Sr., Wesley |
| T | Mike Long, Sr., Delaware Valley | Robbie Ustruck, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| G | Matt Weber, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Nathan Kater, Sr., Heidelberg |
| C | Josh Ostrue, Sr., St. Thomas | Chad Schenkel, Sr., Franklin |
| G | Anthony West, Sr., Wesley | Tony Opperman, Jr., Case Western Reserve |
| T | Pete Soehner, Sr., St. John Fisher | Max Taylor, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| Defense | ||
| DE | Eddie Vallery, Sr., Wittenberg | Chris Mayes, Jr., Wesley |
| DT | Kyle Schroeder, Sr., St. John's | Tyler Owens, Sr., Thomas More |
| DT | Adam Kattoua, Sr., Wittenberg | Paul Nishizaki, Sr., Linfield |
| DE | Alex Wertheimer, Sr., Occidental | Andrew Johnson, Sr., Bethel |
| LB | Kyle Gesswein, Sr., Delaware Valley | Kyle McGivney, Sr., Luther |
| LB | Sam Kershaw, Sr., Mount Union | Matt Wenger, Sr., North Central (Ill.) |
| LB | Will Hawkins, Sr., Millsaps | Ralph Pineda, Sr., Willamette |
| CB | Chris Greenwood, Jr., Albion | Chris Lauda, Sr., Kean |
| S | Drew Fisher, Jr., Linfield | Keith Anthony, Jr., Huntingdon |
| S | Bill Doody, Sr., Hampden-Sydney | Aaron Benson, Sr., Wesley |
| CB | Brandon Brown, Sr., Washington U. | Zach Autenreib, So., Thomas More |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Dan Winsey, Sr., Concordia (Wis.) | Garrett Biel, So., Trinity (Texas) |
| P | Tyler Funk, Sr., Carthage | Kyle Trella, So., Trinity (Texas) |
| RET | Fritz Waldvogel, Jr., St. Thomas | Jeremy Dixon, Sr., Averett |