| Date | Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | ||
| Sep. 25 | Hamline | 14 | Bethel | 41 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | UW-Eau Claire | 14 | UW-Oshkosh | 16 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Southern Ore. | 23 | Pacific Lutheran | 47 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Rowan | 49 | New Jersey City | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | UW-Platteville | 20 | UW-Whitewater | 55 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Southwest Assemblies of God | 0 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 48 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | North Central (Ill.) | 0 | Chicago | 7 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Alma | 46 | Franklin | 38 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Linfield | 28 | Menlo | 19 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | St. John's | 34 | St. Thomas | 18 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Cal Lutheran | 3 | Whitworth | 28 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Johns Hopkins | 20 | Merchant Marine | 24 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Delaware Valley | 27 | Widener | 40 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Concordia-Moorhead | 35 | Carleton | 6 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Wesley | 19 | Butler | 34 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Salisbury | 13 | Greensboro | 42 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Dubuque | 27 | Coe | 63 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Ohio Northern | 24 | Mount Union | 56 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Union | 20 | Hobart | 14 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Hiram | 6 | Heidelberg | 50 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Wittenberg | 62 | Earlham | 6 | Final | |
| Sep. 24 | St. John Fisher | 2 | Hartwick | 38 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | William Paterson | 7 | Western Connecticut | 47 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Worcester State | 17 | Bridgewater State | 41 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Ky. Wesleyan | 51 | Westminster (Mo.) | 35 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Occidental | 14 | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 23 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Pomona-Pitzer | 65 | Oberlin | 0 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Beloit | 47 | Monmouth | 13 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Azusa Pacific | 59 | Redlands | 52 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Williams | 42 | Bowdoin | 0 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Carroll | 7 | Ripon | 36 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Knox | 34 | Illinois College | 35 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Frostburg State | 24 | Methodist | 10 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | UW-Stout | 20 | UW-Stevens Point | 24 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Hope | 11 | Illinois Wesleyan | 19 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Newport News | 20 | Chowan | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Simpson | 7 | Upper Iowa | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Humboldt St. | 9 | Willamette | 3 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Wilkes | 21 | Juniata | 38 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Wabash | 34 | Mount St. Joseph | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Buffalo State | 20 | Cortland | 17 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Blackburn | 6 | Millikin | 63 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Middlebury | 21 | Wesleyan | 28 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Hardin-Simmons | 35 | Southwestern (Kan.) | 9 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Lawrence | 14 | St. Norbert | 43 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Washington U. | 42 | Case Western Reserve | 7 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Davidson | 13 | Emory and Henry | 17 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Simon Fraser | 26 | Lewis and Clark | 7 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Alfred | 7 | Carnegie Mellon | 31 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Eureka | 12 | Benedictine | 0 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Sul Ross State | 12 | Western N.M. | 47 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Springfield | 20 | Coast Guard | 31 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Millsaps | 37 | Colorado College | 40 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | UW-La Crosse | 19 | UW-River Falls | 18 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Trinity (Conn.) | 35 | Colby | 3 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Mississippi College | 16 | Jacksonville | 13 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Olivet | 24 | Defiance | 42 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Manchester | 23 | Albion | 49 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Maryville (Tenn.) | 24 | Cumberland | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Ohio Wesleyan | 3 | Allegheny | 17 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Maine Maritime | 22 | Massachusetts Maritime | 28 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Rose-Hulman | 20 | Kalamazoo | 15 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Maranatha Baptist | 28 | Northwestern (Minn.) | 27 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Centre | 17 | Washington and Lee | 23 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Thiel | 8 | Thomas More | 14 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Marietta | 7 | Baldwin-Wallace | 44 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Concordia (Wis.) | 16 | Lakeland | 30 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Muhlenberg | 42 | Franklin and Marshall | 13 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Susquehanna | 42 | Dickinson | 6 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Bridgewater | 14 | Ferrum | 7 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Capital | 21 | Muskingum | 42 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Luther | 7 | Central | 43 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Mass.-Boston | 6 | Mass-Dartmouth | 58 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Tufts | 28 | Hamilton | 25 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Westfield State | 20 | Fitchburg State | 34 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | St. Lawrence | 17 | Rochester | 28 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Western New England | 7 | Nichols | 19 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Hampden-Sydney | 15 | Guilford | 17 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Cornell | 13 | Wartburg | 56 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | St. Olaf | 27 | Augsburg | 30 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | RPI | 42 | WPI | 27 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Bethany | 3 | Grove City | 24 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Otterbein | 24 | John Carroll | 27 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Lake Forest | 21 | Grinnell | 24 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Gustavus Adolphus | 49 | Macalester | 6 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | DePauw | 0 | Trinity (Texas) | 44 | Final | BX |
| Sep. 25 | Loras | 32 | William Penn | 20 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Ithaca | 21 | TCNJ | 14 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Howard Payne | 20 | Chapman | 29 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Plymouth State | 17 | Norwich | 7 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Framingham State | 20 | Curry | 16 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Amherst | 7 | Bates | 19 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Gettysburg | 55 | Swarthmore | 8 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Aurora | 20 | MacMurray | 13 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Washington and Jefferson | 13 | Hanover | 30 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | MIT | 14 | Salve Regina | 53 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Montclair State | 30 | Brockport | 15 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | King's | 0 | Lycoming | 42 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Albright | 3 | FDU-Florham | 24 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Wilmington | 47 | Adrian | 21 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Lebanon Valley | 24 | Moravian | 13 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Ursinus | 15 | McDaniel | 36 | Final | |
| Sep. 25 | Kenyon | 8 | Wooster | 45 | Final |