|
First Team |
Second Team |
|
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Chris Sharpe, Sr., Springfield | Greg Micheli, Jr., Mount Union |
| RB | Justin Beaver, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Vance Schuring, Sr., Central |
| RB | Nate Kmic, Jr., Mount Union | Jarvis Thrasher, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| WR | Pierre Garcon, Sr., Mount Union | Larry Beavers, Jr., Wesley |
| WR | Derick Alexander, Sr., Capital | Jack Martin, Sr., Washington and Lee |
| TE | Chris Harmon, Sr., St. John Fisher | Maurice Coleman, Jr., Shenandoah |
| T | Dustin Connolly, Sr., Union | Caleb Woodall, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| G | Jon Verhelst, Sr., Augustana | Jordan Purdy, Sr., Wilkes |
| C | Eric Safran, Sr., Mount Union | Andrew Salvato, Sr., St. John's |
| G | Derek Blanchard, Sr., Mount Union | Jon Stavast, Sr., Luther |
| T | Brennan Fortune, Sr., St. John Fisher | Brandon Bennett, Sr., Willamette |
|
Defense |
||
| DE | Andy Studebaker, Sr., Wheaton | Matt Rugenstein, Sr., Hope |
| DT | Nick Gunderson, Jr., St. John's | James McLaughlin, Jr., RPI |
| DE | Bryan Robinson, Sr., Wesley | Andrew Eisentrout, Sr., Pacific Lutheran |
| LB | Kyle Follweiler, Sr., Wilkes | Leonard Trusnik, Sr., Ohio Northern |
| LB | A.J. Raebel, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Tom Brew, Sr., Case Western Reserve |
| LB | Jerrell Freeman, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Cody Pierce, Sr., Buena Vista |
| LB | Adrian Pynenberg, Sr., Wabash | Paul Burger, Jr., Baldwin-Wallace |
| CB | Steve Stepnick, Sr., St. John Fisher | Pete Ittersagen, Jr., Wheaton |
| S | Matt Kostelnik, Sr., Mount Union | Jay Tully, Sr., Whitworth |
| S | Brandon Carr, Sr., Bethel | Steve Arguelles, So., Coast Guard |
| CB | Drew Gallaugher, Sr., Colorado College | Nick Cass, Sr., Defiance |
|
Specialists |
||
| K | Jeff Schebler, So., UW-Whitewater | Josh Whiteside, Sr., Allegheny |
| P | Kevin Soflkiancs, Sr., Baldwin-Wallace | Jonathan Russell, Sr., Mississippi College |
| RET | Isaac Blum, Jr., Puget Sound | Dustin Locke, Sr., Maryville |