Offensive Player of the Year: Nate Kmic, So.,
Mount Union
Defensive Player of the Year: Ryan Kleppe, Sr.,
UW-Whitewater
Coach of the Year: Larry Kehres, Mount Union
| First Team | Second Team | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Rocky Pentello, Sr., Capital | Joel Clark, Sr., Whitworth |
| RB | Justin Beaver, Jr., UW-Whitewater | Mark Robinson, Sr., St. John Fisher |
| RB | Nate Kmic, So., Mount Union | Tom Arcidiacono, Sr., Union |
| WR | Pierre Garcon, Jr., Mount Union | Jon Branche, Sr., RPI |
| WR | Chris Barnette, Sr., Guilford | Derick Alexander, Jr., Capital |
| TE | Michael Allan, Sr., Whitworth | Pete Schmitt, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| T | Max Sakellaris, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Ryan Wassink, Sr., Bethel |
| G | Adam Feit, Sr., Springfield | Chris Hickey, Sr., Washington & Jefferson |
| C | Josh Knox, Sr., Hardin-Simmons | Eric Safran, Jr., Mount Union |
| G | Derek Blanchard, Jr., Mount Union | J.P. White, Sr., Carnegie Mellon |
| T | Jason Lewis, Sr., Mount Union | Brennan Fortune, Jr., St. John Fisher |
|
Defense |
||
| DE | Andy Studebaker, Jr., Wheaton | Bryan Robinson, Jr., Wesley |
| DT | Ryan Kleppe, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Anthony Serafin, Sr., Wilkes |
| DT | Adam Haas, Sr., Cortland State | Chris Jones, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| DE | Justen Stickley, Sr., Mount Union | Keith Heimerl, Sr., Rowan |
| LB | Taz Wallace, Sr., Adrian | Kyle Follweiler, Jr., Wilkes |
| LB | Gene Lang, Sr., St. John Fisher | A.J. Raebel, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| LB | Jerrell Freeman, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Adrian Pynenberg, Jr., Wabash |
| CB | Steve Teeples, Sr., UW-La Crosse | Steve Stepnick, Jr., St. John Fisher |
| S | Josh Kubiak, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Matt Kostelnik, Jr., Mount Union |
| S | Chad Otte, Sr., Wilmington | Aaron Lewis, Sr., Carnegie Mellon |
| CB | Rob Rodriguez, Sr., Christopher Newport | Dawaine Whetstone, Sr., Rowan |
|
Specialists |
||
| K | Zach Newcomb, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jeff Schebler, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| P | Kevin Soflkiancs, Jr., Baldwin-Wallace | Ben Scott, Sr., Johns Hopkins |
| RET | Chris Jackson, Sr., Millsaps | Kelly Gordon, Sr., Ithaca |
| Third Team | Honorable Mention | |
|
Offense |
||
| QB | Andy Collins, Sr., Occidental | Chris Sharpe, Jr., Springfield |
| RB | Phil Porta, Sr. Bethel | Vance Schuring, Jr., Central |
| RB | Tristan Murray, Sr., Wittenberg | Roland Hilliard, Sr., Christopher Newport |
| WR | Jon Drenckhahn, Sr., Williams | Joe Cline, Jr., Alma |
| WR | Derek Stanley, Sr., UW-Whitewater | Michael Clarke, Jr., Wesley |
| TE | Dylan Kelly, Sr., Capital | Ryan Stearrett, Sr., Dickinson |
| T | Ryan Glassman, Sr., Carthage | Caleb Woodall, Jr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| G | Nick Reed, Sr., Central | Jordan Purdy, Jr., Wilkes |
| C | Josh Kinniard, Sr., Capital | Chris Kenney, Sr., Williams |
| G | Jon Verhelst, Jr., Augustana | Jon Stavast, Jr., Luther |
| T | Dustin Connolly, Jr., Union | Brandon Bennett, Jr., Willamette |
|
Defense |
||
| DE | Kevin McNamara, Sr., St. John's | Dustin Hertel, Sr., DePauw |
| DT | Adam Helmerich, Sr., Rose-Hulman | Terrance Carroll, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| DT | Dustin Allen, Sr., Trinity (Texas) | Nick Gunderson, So., St. John's |
| DE | Jason Trusnik, Sr., Ohio Northern | Anthony Silver, Sr., Delaware Valley |
| LB | Tom Brew, Sr., Case Western Reserve | Mark Carlisle, Sr., Thomas More |
| LB | Cody Pierce, Jr., Buena Vista | Jason Allen, Sr., Hanover |
| LB | Eric Dube, Jr., Dickinson | Sean Crowley, Sr., Curry |
| CB | Drew Gallaugher, Jr., Colorado College | Pete Ittersagen, So., Wheaton |
| S | Craig Haywood, Sr., King's | Steve Arguelles, Fr., Coast Guard |
| S | Brandon Carr, Jr., Bethel | Timothy Bellazzini, Sr., North Central |
| CB | Byron Westbrook, Sr., Salisbury | Mike Ferriero, Sr., Wilkes |
| Specialists | ||
| K | Ben Scott, Sr., Johns Hopkins | Vin Doffont, Sr., Montclair State |
| P | Jesse Harms, Jr., Coast Guard | Dom Ancona, Jr., Hobart |
| RET | Jihad Mahasin, Sr., Menlo | Byron Westbrook, Sr., Salisbury |